Dutasteride or Finasteride for a Large Prostate: Who Benefits, the Six-Month Wait, PSA Rules and Pairing With Tamsulosin

👨⚕️ Most men who start treatment for an enlarged prostate are given a tablet that relaxes the muscle around the urethra, and within a week or two the stream feels easier. For a large gland, that is only half of the job. Dutasteride and finasteride are the only tablets that actually make the prostate smaller, and over the years they lower the chance of being unable to pass urine or needing an operation. 🔍 They also work slowly, change the PSA blood test, and carry sexual side effects that worry many men. This guide explains who really benefits from a 5-alpha reductase inhibitor, why it takes about six months, how much the gland shrinks, when it is paired with tamsulosin in one capsule, how to read PSA while taking it, and how Avosteride, Avodart, Proscar and Prosacar compare.
⏱️ Two kinds of prostate tablet, two different clocks
🚻 Benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) causes trouble in two ways. The gland grows and narrows the channel, and the smooth muscle inside it tightens and squeezes the urethra further. Alpha blockers such as tamsulosin treat the squeeze; 5-alpha reductase inhibitors treat the growth. The first group starts working within days, the second needs months. Most disappointment with dutasteride or finasteride comes from expecting them to behave like tamsulosin. 📖 For the full picture of symptoms, scoring and all the treatment options, see benign prostatic hyperplasia: which drug works in days and which takes months.
🧬 What these tablets do inside the prostate
🔬 Prostate cells grow in response to dihydrotestosterone (DHT), a stronger hormone made from testosterone by an enzyme called 5-alpha reductase. Block the enzyme and DHT inside the prostate falls sharply, so the gland slowly stops growing and the glandular tissue shrinks. Testosterone itself stays normal or rises a little, which is why these drugs are not castration and do not cause the hot flushes and muscle loss seen with hormone therapy for prostate cancer. 📖 Hormone treatment for cancer is a different story, covered in hormonal therapy for prostate cancer.
⚖️ Dutasteride and finasteride side by side
💊 The two drugs belong to the same class but are not identical. Finasteride blocks the type 2 enzyme, while dutasteride blocks both type 1 and type 2, so it lowers blood DHT further. In head-to-head studies of men with BPH, the two gave very similar results for symptoms, urine flow and prostate shrinkage, so the choice usually comes down to price, availability and how a man tolerates the tablet.
| 🔍 Feature | 💊 Dutasteride | 💊 Finasteride |
|---|---|---|
| Dose for BPH | 0.5 mg once daily | 5 mg once daily |
| Enzyme types blocked | Type 1 and type 2 | Type 2 |
| Drop in blood DHT | about 90% or more | about 70% |
| Time in the body after stopping | Weeks to months (half-life about 5 weeks) | Days |
| Form | Soft capsule, swallow whole | Tablet |
| Blood donation | Not until 6 months after the last dose | Not until about 1 month after |
📏 Who benefits: prostate size is the key
📐 These drugs only help when there is enough prostate to shrink. Guidelines recommend them for men with bothersome symptoms and an enlarged gland, usually over 30 to 40 mL, measured by ultrasound or estimated by examination and PSA. A normal adult prostate is around 20 to 25 mL. In very large glands of 60 or 80 mL the shrinking effect matters most, because these are the men most at risk of their condition getting worse over time.
🧪 Why PSA is used as a clue to prostate size
📊 PSA is a protein made by prostate cells, so a bigger gland usually releases more of it into the blood. In men without cancer, a PSA above about 1.5 ng/mL suggests a prostate large enough to respond to a 5-alpha reductase inhibitor, and it also predicts a higher chance of future retention or surgery. It is a rough estimate: infection, recent ejaculation, cycling and cancer can all raise PSA, and an ultrasound gives a far better measure of volume when the decision is close.
💡 A baseline PSA taken before the first dose is worth its weight. Once treatment starts, every later PSA result is judged against that starting number, so a missing baseline makes follow-up much harder for the doctor and can lead to unnecessary biopsies or missed rises.
🚫 Who gains little from them
🤔 Not every man with prostate symptoms has a large prostate. Many have a small or average gland with an overactive bladder, a narrow bladder neck or symptoms driven by drinking patterns, coffee, diabetes or night-time urine production. In these men, shrinking the prostate does not fix the problem, and the sexual side effects are not worth taking for no gain. Men whose main complaint is a sudden urge with spasms often do better with bladder-focused treatment; see bladder storm: how to calm urinary spasms.
- 📌 Prostate measured under 30 mL on ultrasound
- 📌 Symptoms mostly at night, with large volumes passed each time
- 📌 Urgency and leaking as the main issue, with a good stream
- 📌 Men who want quick relief only and do not plan long-term treatment
🗓️ The six-month wait, month by month
⏳ DHT drops within days, but tissue shrinks slowly. Most men notice nothing in the first three months, a clear change by six, and the full effect by about twelve. This is why urologists often ask men to give the tablet at least six months before calling it a failure, and why an alpha blocker is usually given alongside it for quick relief in the meantime.
📉 How much the prostate shrinks
📐 In the large trials, the average gland lost roughly a quarter of its volume over one to two years, and some men lost more. The shrinkage is real but modest; a 70 mL prostate will not return to 25 mL. What matters is that the gland stops growing, while in untreated men it usually keeps enlarging slowly year after year.
🛑 Lowering the risk of retention and surgery
🚑 Acute urinary retention, the sudden inability to pass urine, is painful and usually means a catheter in an emergency department. Over four years of treatment, finasteride and dutasteride roughly halved the risk of acute retention and of needing prostate surgery compared with placebo in men with enlarged glands. This is something alpha blockers alone do not do, because they leave the gland growing. For a man with a large prostate who wants to avoid an operation, this long-term effect is the main reason to take the tablet.
Risk about halved over 4 years
Risk about halved over 4 years
Improves slowly, then holds
🩸 Blood in the urine from the prostate
🔴 Large prostates have fragile surface veins that can bleed, causing pink urine or clots. Once a doctor has ruled out bladder cancer, kidney stones and infection, finasteride is often used to reduce this prostatic bleeding, because lower DHT reduces the blood supply to the gland. It is an accepted use in urology clinics, though it is not on every label. Any visible blood in the urine must be checked first; it should never be put down to the prostate without tests.
🤝 Combination with tamsulosin
➕ For men with moderate to severe symptoms and a large prostate, many urologists use both classes together. In long-term trials, the combination reduced the risk of the condition getting worse more than either drug alone, and gave both the quick relief of the alpha blocker and the shrinking effect of the 5-alpha reductase inhibitor. The price is more side effects, especially ejaculation changes, because each drug adds its own. 📖 How tamsulosin is taken, and its first-dose dizziness and eye surgery warning, are covered in tamsulosin for an enlarged prostate.
💡 Tamsulosin is available as Flomax (Tamsulosin). After 6 to 12 months of combined treatment, some men can try stopping the alpha blocker and keep only the 5-alpha reductase inhibitor, if the symptoms stay controlled. Others need both for good. This is a test worth doing with the doctor, since it removes one source of side effects.
💊 One capsule or two separate tablets
📦 A fixed combination capsule containing dutasteride 0.5 mg and tamsulosin 0.4 mg (sold in some countries under the brand Jalyn or Combodart) is taken once a day, about 30 minutes after the same meal each day. Clinically it is the same as taking the two medicines separately, just with one capsule instead of two. Separate tablets give more flexibility: the alpha blocker can be stopped or swapped without losing the 5-alpha reductase inhibitor, and the doses can be adjusted on their own.
| 🔍 Point | 💊 Fixed capsule | 💊 Two separate medicines |
|---|---|---|
| Number of pills | One | Two |
| Timing | 30 minutes after the same meal | Tamsulosin after a meal, 5-ARI any time |
| Stopping one drug | Needs a new prescription | Simple |
| Effect | Same | Same |
🌳 Which approach fits which man
🔢 The PSA doubling rule
🧪 Dutasteride and finasteride lower PSA by about half after six months of treatment, in men with and without cancer. To compare with normal ranges, doctors double the PSA measured on treatment; a result of 1.8 ng/mL on dutasteride is read as about 3.6. The free-to-total PSA ratio does not need adjusting. Tell every doctor who orders a PSA that you take one of these drugs, including at a routine health check, or a normal-looking number may hide a real rise.
Baseline PSA, for example 3.0
New low point, about 1.5
Should stay near the low point
From the low point needs review
⚠️ A PSA that does not fall at all after six months may also be a signal. It can mean the tablet is not being taken regularly, or that the PSA is coming from something other than benign growth, and doctors usually look more closely in that case.
🔬 Prostate cancer and the high-grade question
📖 Two very large prevention trials gave finasteride or dutasteride to healthy men to see whether they would prevent prostate cancer. Overall, fewer cancers were found in the treated men, but slightly more high-grade tumours were detected, and regulators added a warning to the labels. Many experts now think this is partly a detection effect, because a smaller prostate makes it easier for a biopsy needle to find a tumour, and long-term follow-up did not show more deaths from prostate cancer. These drugs are not approved to prevent cancer, and they do not replace normal cancer checks.
🧭 What this means for a man with BPH:
🔹 Have a baseline PSA and, where advised, a prostate examination before starting.
🔹 Use the doubling rule and watch for any rise from the low point.
🔹 Report new bone pain, weight loss or blood in the semen or urine.
❤️ Sexual side effects: what to expect
📋 Sexual effects are the main reason men stop these tablets. In the BPH trials, lower sex drive, erection problems and reduced semen volume each affected a few men in every hundred more than placebo, most often in the first year, and became less frequent later. Men on combination therapy have more ejaculation problems because tamsulosin adds its own. Most of these effects ease after stopping, although dutasteride clears slowly, so recovery can take longer.
| 📋 Effect | 📝 What men notice | ⏱️ Course |
|---|---|---|
| Lower libido | Less interest in sex | Often fades in the first year |
| Erection problems | Harder to get or keep | Usually reversible |
| Less semen | Smaller volume, sometimes thicker | Common, harmless |
| Dry or reduced ejaculation | Mostly with added tamsulosin | Stops when tamsulosin stops |
| Breast tenderness or growth | Sore or swollen breast tissue | Report to a doctor |
💡 Erection problems are common in men of the same age anyway, and many have causes in the heart, blood vessels or diabetes. A new problem on treatment deserves a check, not just an assumption that the tablet is to blame. 📖 See erectile dysfunction: a clear practical guide and when desire fades: reduced libido.
😔 Breast changes, mood and rare effects
⚠️ Breast tenderness or enlargement affects a small number of men, and any lump, nipple discharge or one-sided swelling must be checked, since male breast cancer has been reported rarely in men on these drugs. Regulators have also listed depressed mood and, for finasteride, suicidal thoughts as possible side effects. These are rare, but men with a history of depression should mention it before starting and stop the tablet if their mood drops. Allergic reactions with rash or swelling of the lips and face are rare and need urgent help.
🧴 Fertility, blood donation and handling capsules
👶 Most men on BPH treatment are past the age of planning a family, but not all. These drugs can lower sperm count, semen volume and sperm movement, changes that recover after stopping. Because the drug can reach a pregnancy through donated blood, men must not donate blood while taking it, and for six months after the last dutasteride dose. Women who are or may become pregnant should not handle leaking dutasteride capsules or crushed finasteride tablets, since the drug can pass through the skin.
⛔ Interactions and who should not take them
🔎 Finasteride has very few drug interactions. Dutasteride is broken down by the liver enzyme CYP3A4, so strong blockers of that enzyme can raise its levels; examples include ritonavir and other HIV boosters, ketoconazole and itraconazole, and clarithromycin. The combination is not always forbidden, but the doctor should know.
| 🚫 Situation | 📝 Why |
|---|---|
| Women and children | Not for use; risk to a male baby during pregnancy |
| Allergy to the drug | Rash, hives, swelling |
| Severe liver disease | Both drugs are cleared by the liver |
| Suspected prostate cancer not yet assessed | PSA will fall and may hide the picture |
| Past depression | Use with care and follow-up |
| Couples trying for a baby | Sperm changes; often postponed |
💊 Tadalafil and other add-ons
💡 Tadalafil 5 mg once a day is approved for the urinary symptoms of BPH and helps erections at the same time. It has been studied together with finasteride for the first months of treatment, covering the slow start and offsetting some of the sexual side effects. It must never be taken with nitrate heart medicines, and doctors are careful when combining it with an alpha blocker because both lower blood pressure. Low-dose options include Cialis (Tadalafil) and Tadaga (Tadalafil).
💧 For bladder spasm and urgency that remain after the stream improves, a urinary antispasmodic such as Urispas (Flavoxate) is sometimes used. Drugs that relax the bladder should be used carefully when the stream is very weak or the bladder does not empty, because they can tip a man into retention.
⏪ What happens if you stop
📈 These tablets control the growth; they do not cure it. After stopping, DHT recovers, the prostate grows back toward its earlier size over months, and the protection against retention fades. PSA also rises back to its untreated level, which needs to be remembered at the next blood test. Men who stop because of side effects should know this trade-off and agree another plan with the doctor, such as an alpha blocker alone, tadalafil or a procedure.
DHT and PSA climb back
Gland returns toward earlier size
Means waiting another 6 months
🏷️ Avosteride, Avodart, Proscar and Prosacar compared
💊 Brand names differ, but the active ingredients do not. Avosteride and Avodart contain dutasteride 0.5 mg; Proscar and Prosacar contain finasteride 5 mg. Generic versions must deliver the same amount of drug into the blood as the original, so the effect on the prostate is the same. The 1 mg finasteride tablets sold for hair loss are too weak for BPH and should not be used for it.
📖 Dutasteride is also used off-label for hair loss at the same 0.5 mg dose, a different goal covered in dutasteride for hair loss. For the prostate, the dose and the daily routine are the same, but the follow-up focuses on urine flow and PSA.
🗿 Myths about prostate-shrinking tablets
📋 Follow-up in the first year
🚨 When to see a doctor
⛔ Get medical help promptly if:
🔹 You cannot pass urine at all and the lower belly is painful and swollen; this needs urgent care the same day.
🔹 You see blood in the urine or pass clots.
🔹 You have fever, shivering or pain between the legs with urinary symptoms.
🔹 Your PSA rises on treatment, or you notice a breast lump or nipple discharge.
🔹 Your mood drops, or you get swelling of the lips, face or throat.
📖 Men who need quick relief while waiting for the 5-alpha reductase inhibitor to work should read how to take tamsulosin. The two medicines are designed to cover each other: one for now, one for the years ahead.
❓ Frequently asked questions
How long does dutasteride take to shrink the prostate?
The gland starts shrinking within the first months, symptoms usually improve clearly by about 6 months, and the full effect is reached at around 12 months.
Is dutasteride better than finasteride for BPH?
Dutasteride lowers DHT more, but in head-to-head studies both gave similar improvements in symptoms, flow and prostate size. Price and tolerance usually decide.
How big does the prostate need to be for these drugs to help?
They are recommended for enlarged glands, usually over 30 to 40 mL, or when PSA is above about 1.5 ng/mL in a man without cancer. In small prostates the benefit is small.
Why is my PSA doubled while I take dutasteride or finasteride?
Both drugs lower PSA by about half after 6 months. Doubling the result allows comparison with normal ranges, and any confirmed rise from the lowest value needs review.
Can I take dutasteride and tamsulosin together?
Yes. The combination is common for large prostates with moderate or severe symptoms and is sold as one capsule in some countries. It works faster and protects longer than either drug alone.
Do these tablets reduce the need for prostate surgery?
Yes. Over four years they roughly halved the risk of acute urinary retention and of needing surgery in men with enlarged prostates, compared with placebo.
What are the sexual side effects of dutasteride for BPH?
Lower libido, erection problems and reduced semen volume affect a few men in every hundred more than placebo, mostly in the first year. Most cases improve after stopping.
What happens if I stop taking finasteride for my prostate?
DHT and PSA return to their earlier levels, the prostate grows back over months and the protection against retention fades. Talk to a doctor about another plan first.
Can I donate blood while taking dutasteride?
No. Men should not donate blood while taking dutasteride or for 6 months after the last dose, so the drug does not reach a pregnant woman through a transfusion.
Is Avosteride the same as Avodart?
Both contain dutasteride 0.5 mg. Generic versions must deliver the same amount of drug into the blood, so the effect on the prostate is the same.
📑 Sources and editorial
- 📘 Prescribing information for dutasteride 0.5 mg and finasteride 5 mg
- 🔬 Long-term placebo-controlled trials of 5-alpha reductase inhibitors in men with enlarged prostates
- 🤝 Four-year trials of combination therapy with an alpha blocker and a 5-alpha reductase inhibitor
- 🩺 Urology association guidelines on the management of lower urinary tract symptoms in men
- 🧪 Prostate cancer prevention trials and guidance on interpreting PSA during 5-alpha reductase inhibitor treatment
- ⚠️ Regulatory safety communications on high-grade prostate cancer, mood changes and blood donation
- 📖 Related reading: benign prostatic hyperplasia, tamsulosin for an enlarged prostate, urinary spasms, erectile dysfunction
- 🛒 Related products: Avosteride (Dutasteride), Avodart (Dutasteride), Proscar (Finasteride), Prosacar (Finasteride), Flomax (Tamsulosin), Cialis (Tadalafil)
- 🩺 RXshop Editorial Team — reviewed by Michael Reeves, MD — Urologist
Medical Disclaimer: The information in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek guidance from a qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition, and before starting, stopping or changing any medication.