Postherpetic Neuralgia Treatment: Gabapentin, Nortriptyline, Lidocaine Plasters and What Helps When Shingles Pain Stays

🧠 The shingles rash has crusted, the skin looks almost normal, yet the same band of skin still burns, stabs or cannot bear the touch of a shirt. When nerve pain lasts three months or more after the rash, doctors call it postherpetic neuralgia (PHN), and it is the most common lasting complication of shingles. 🔍 PHN is not a sign that the virus is still active, and antivirals do not treat it once it has set in. What helps is a different group of medicines that calm overactive nerves: gabapentin and pregabalin, low-dose nortriptyline or amitriptyline, lidocaine plasters and capsaicin. This guide explains how each one is started, how long to give it, what side effects to expect, how they are combined, and what is left when tablets are not enough.
🧬 Why the pain stays after the rash heals
🔬 Shingles is a reactivation of the chickenpox virus inside a sensory nerve root. As the virus travels down the nerve, it inflames and damages the nerve fibres and the nerve cell bodies in the ganglion beside the spine. In PHN, the damaged nerve keeps firing pain signals even though there is no longer any injury in the skin. Some fibres are lost, others become hypersensitive and fire on their own, and the spinal cord learns to amplify whatever input it still receives. 📖 For the acute illness itself, the 72-hour antiviral window and the danger signs, see shingles: the 72-hour window and antiviral doses. This article starts where that one ends: when the rash is gone and the pain is not.
🔥 What postherpetic neuralgia feels like
🗣️ People describe PHN in very different words, and the words matter because they hint at which treatment may help most. The most typical and most distressing feature is allodynia: pain from something that should not hurt at all, such as clothing, bed sheets, a light breeze or a shower. The pain stays inside the same band of skin where the rash was, on one side of the body, most often on the chest, back or forehead.
👥 Who is most likely to get PHN
📊 The single strongest risk factor is age. PHN is uncommon under 50 and becomes much more frequent with every decade after 60, because older nerves recover less well and the immune response to the virus is weaker. Severe pain during the rash, a large or dense rash, and pain that started days before the rash also predict a higher risk.
⏳ How long PHN lasts
📆 The honest answer is that it varies, but the general direction is good. Most PHN slowly improves, and many people are much better within a year, although a minority keep some pain for years. Treatment does not have to be lifelong; it is reviewed and tapered as the nerve settles.
🩺 How the diagnosis is made
🔎 PHN is a clinical diagnosis. A history of shingles in the same band of skin plus lasting neuropathic pain is usually enough, and no scan or blood test is needed in typical cases. The doctor will examine the area, test touch and pinprick, and look for scarring or colour change from the old rash.
| 🔎 Look-alike | 📋 Clue | 🧪 Usual check |
|---|---|---|
| Recurrent shingles | New blisters in the same or another area | Examination, swab if unsure |
| Trapped nerve in the spine | Pain linked to movement, neck or back pain | Examination, sometimes MRI |
| Heart, gallbladder or kidney pain | Chest or flank pain without skin sensitivity | ECG, blood tests, ultrasound |
| Diabetic or other neuropathy | Both feet or hands, not one band | Blood sugar, vitamin B12 |
| Trigeminal neuralgia | Face attacks without a past rash | Neurological assessment |
📖 Face pain that comes in electric attacks without any shingles history is covered in trigeminal neuralgia: face pain, tablets and surgery.
🎯 Setting a realistic goal
📏 Nerve pain medicines rarely switch pain off completely. A drop of about a third is felt as a real improvement, and halving the pain is an excellent result. Agreeing this goal at the start prevents a common trap: stopping a medicine that is working partly, or pushing the dose until side effects outweigh the benefit. Better sleep and normal clothes matter as much as the pain score.
🪜 The treatment ladder at a glance
📋 International guidance for neuropathic pain, and for PHN in particular, places three groups at the start: gabapentinoids, tricyclic antidepressants and topical lidocaine. The choice between them depends on the age of the patient, other illnesses, other medicines and whether the pain is mainly allodynia in a small area or a deep burn over a wide one.
| 💊 Option | 📍 Place in treatment | ✅ Best suited when |
|---|---|---|
| Gabapentin or pregabalin | First line | Burning and stabbing pain, poor sleep, many other medicines |
| Nortriptyline or amitriptyline | First line | Night pain, poor sleep, no heart rhythm problems |
| Lidocaine 5% plaster | First line, local | Small area of allodynia, older or frail patients |
| Capsaicin 8% patch | Second line, in clinic | Localised pain not helped by plasters or tablets |
| Duloxetine | Alternative, off-label | Pain with depression or anxiety |
| Tramadol or other opioids | Later, short term | Severe pain while first-line drugs are being built up |
💊 Gabapentin: how it is started and built up
⚙️ Gabapentin binds to a part of calcium channels on overactive nerve endings and reduces the release of pain-signalling chemicals. It is approved for PHN and is often the first tablet tried, because it has few drug interactions and no effect on heart rhythm. The key is slow building: a dose that is too low does nothing, and a dose raised too quickly causes dizziness and drowsiness. Options include Neurontin (Gabapentin) and Gabatop (Gabapentin).
📊 In placebo-controlled trials in PHN, roughly a third of people on gabapentin reached at least half the pain they started with, compared with about one in six on placebo. So a fair trial and a clear stop rule matter.
⚠️ Gabapentin side effects and safety
😵 Dizziness and sleepiness are the most common side effects and usually ease after the first two weeks at a stable dose. Other effects include unsteadiness, ankle swelling, weight gain and blurred vision. Gabapentin should not be stopped suddenly after weeks of use; it is reduced over at least a week to avoid withdrawal symptoms and rebound pain.
🧭 Practical safety points:
🔹 Do not drive until you know how the dose affects you.
🔹 Avoid alcohol and take extra care with opioids, sleeping tablets and other sedatives, which add to drowsiness and can slow breathing.
🔹 Gabapentin can be misused; keep it for your own use and store it safely.
🔄 Pregabalin: the close relative
💊 Pregabalin works in the same way as gabapentin and is also approved for PHN. It is absorbed more predictably and is taken twice a day, so the effective dose is reached faster, often within a week. A common range is 150 to 300 mg a day, with up to 600 mg used in some patients, and lower doses when the kidneys are weaker. Its side effects mirror those of gabapentin: dizziness, sleepiness, swelling and weight gain. If one gabapentinoid fails because of side effects, the other is sometimes better tolerated, but taking both together brings no extra benefit.
🌙 Nortriptyline and amitriptyline
🧪 Tricyclic antidepressants were among the first medicines shown to help PHN, and at the low doses used for pain they work on nerve signalling, not on mood. They boost the pain-dampening pathways of the brain that run down the spinal cord. Because they are sedating, they are taken once, at night, which often improves sleep at the same time. Nortriptyline is usually preferred in older adults because it causes less dry mouth, constipation and dizziness on standing than amitriptyline.
⏰ Take the dose 1 to 2 hours before bed to limit morning grogginess. The dose is usually raised every week or two by 10 to 25 mg, and the full effect on pain appears over 4 to 6 weeks.
🚫 Who should be careful with tricyclics
| 🚫 Situation | 📝 Why |
|---|---|
| Recent heart attack, heart block, rhythm problems | Tricyclics can slow electrical conduction in the heart; an ECG is often done first in people over 40 or with heart disease |
| Narrow-angle glaucoma | Can raise eye pressure |
| Enlarged prostate, urinary retention | Harder to pass urine |
| Frail older people, risk of falls | Dizziness on standing, confusion |
| MAOI antidepressants, or other drugs that raise serotonin | Risk of serious interactions |
| History of overdose or suicidal thoughts | Tricyclics are dangerous in overdose; small supplies and close follow-up |
🩹 Lidocaine 5% plasters
🧴 A lidocaine 5% plaster is placed directly on the most painful skin. It numbs the overactive nerve endings locally, and very little of the drug reaches the bloodstream, so it suits older people and those on many medicines. It also shields the skin from rubbing clothes. The usual pattern is up to three plasters over the painful area for 12 hours, then 12 hours without, and the plasters can be cut to shape.
Few whole-body side effects, no dose building, works on touch pain
Only for intact skin and a limited area; mild redness or itch where applied
About 2 to 4 weeks of regular use
🌶️ Capsaicin cream and the high-strength patch
🔥 Capsaicin is the substance that makes chilli peppers hot. Applied to the skin, it first stimulates and then exhausts the pain fibres, which pull back from the surface for weeks. The high-strength 8% patch is applied in a clinic for 60 minutes and can give relief that lasts up to about three months; the area is usually numbed first because the application itself burns. Low-strength creams are used three or four times a day, sting at first and need several weeks of regular use, so many people give up before they work.
➕ Combining treatments
🔗 When one medicine helps only partly, adding a second from a different group is often better than pushing one drug to its maximum. A trial in neuropathic pain, including PHN, found that gabapentin plus nortriptyline gave more relief than either alone, at lower doses of each. The cost is that drowsiness adds up, so the second drug starts low. Plasters combine easily with any tablet because they add almost nothing to whole-body side effects.
💠 Duloxetine and other second options
💊 Duloxetine, a serotonin and noradrenaline reuptake inhibitor, is approved for diabetic nerve pain and is used off-label in PHN, where the direct evidence is thinner. It is a reasonable choice when nerve pain comes with depression or anxiety, or when tricyclics are unsafe for the heart. A usual dose is 60 mg once a day, often starting at 30 mg to reduce nausea. It should not be combined with a tricyclic or other serotonin drugs without specialist advice. Options include Cymbalta (Duloxetine). 📖 How the same medicines are used for nerve pain in diabetes is explained in diabetic neuropathy: more than tingling.
💉 When tablets are not enough
🏥 A small group of people still have severe pain after trying two or three first-line treatments properly. They should be referred to a pain clinic, where several procedures can be considered. Evidence for each is mixed, and results vary between people.
🤏 Neuropathic itch after shingles
🐜 Some people have little pain but an intense, deep itch in the old rash area, called postherpetic itch. It comes from the damaged nerve, not from the skin, so scratching gives no relief and can break the numb skin without the person feeling it. Ordinary antihistamines usually help little. The same tools used for pain are tried: lidocaine plasters, capsaicin, and gabapentin or pregabalin. Short nails and a cover at night protect the skin.
🛌 Sleep, mood and daily life
💤 Constant nerve pain wears people down. Poor sleep makes pain feel worse, and pain makes sleep worse, a loop that often deepens into low mood. Treating sleep and mood is part of treating PHN, which is one reason night-time tricyclics or duloxetine are chosen in some patients.
👴 Older patients: extra care with doses
🧓 Most people with PHN are over 60, and that changes how treatment is given. Kidney function falls with age, so gabapentin and pregabalin build up in the blood at doses that are fine for younger adults. Tricyclics add a risk of confusion, constipation, urinary retention and dizziness on standing. The rule is to start low, go slow, and check balance, memory and blood pressure at each step. Plasters are often the first choice in frail patients for exactly this reason.
🛡️ Can PHN be prevented with antivirals?
⏱️ Antivirals started within 72 hours of the rash shorten the shingles attack, reduce acute pain and speed healing. Their effect on preventing PHN itself is more modest than many people think, but in trials famciclovir and valacyclovir shortened the time that pain lasted after the rash, and early treatment remains the best step available during the attack. Once PHN has developed, more antivirals do not help, because the virus is no longer the problem.
| 💊 Antiviral | 📋 Usual adult dose for shingles | 📝 Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Famvir (Famciclovir) | 500 mg three times daily for 7 days | Also as Virovir (Famciclovir) |
| Valtrex (Valacyclovir) | 1000 mg three times daily for 7 days | Well absorbed, widely used |
| Zovirax (Acyclovir) | 800 mg five times daily for 7 days | Effective, but more doses a day |
💧 All three are cleared by the kidneys, and doses are reduced in kidney disease. 📖 How valacyclovir works across herpes infections is explained in treating herpes with valacyclovir.
💉 The shingles vaccine
🛡️ The most effective way to avoid PHN is to avoid shingles. The recombinant shingles vaccine, given as two doses two to six months apart, protects strongly against shingles and therefore against PHN, and its protection holds well for years. It is recommended for adults aged 50 and over in many countries. People who have already had shingles, and even those living with PHN, are usually advised to have it once the acute attack has settled, to lower the chance of a second episode.
📅 How long to give each treatment
2 to 4 weeks
About 4 weeks
3 to 8 weeks of building, then 2 at the top dose
6 to 8 weeks, with 2 at the best dose
🗿 Myths about postherpetic neuralgia
🚨 When to see a doctor
⛔ Get medical advice soon if:
🔹 Pain after shingles has lasted more than a month and is disturbing sleep or daily life.
🔹 You have new blisters, a rash in a new place, or pain spreading beyond the original band.
🔹 Shingles affected the area around the eye and you now have eye pain, redness or blurred vision.
🔹 A medicine causes confusion, falls, fainting, a racing or irregular heartbeat, or trouble passing urine.
🔹 You feel hopeless or have thoughts of harming yourself. In that case, contact emergency services or a crisis line now.
📖 Other nerve pain conditions that share the same medicines are covered in alcoholic neuropathy: causes and treatment and diabetic neuropathy.
❓ Frequently asked questions
What is the best treatment for postherpetic neuralgia?
There is no single best option. First-line choices are gabapentin or pregabalin, low-dose nortriptyline or amitriptyline, and lidocaine 5% plasters, chosen by age, other illnesses and the type of pain.
How long does postherpetic neuralgia last?
It varies. Most people improve gradually and many are much better within a year, but a smaller group has pain for several years and needs long-term care.
How much gabapentin is used for shingles nerve pain?
A common plan starts at 300 mg on day one and rises to 300 mg three times a day by day three, then up to about 1800 mg a day if needed. Lower doses are used in older people and in kidney disease.
How long does gabapentin take to work for PHN?
Some relief may appear in the first week, but a fair judgement needs several weeks of building the dose and about two weeks at the target dose.
Is nortriptyline or amitriptyline better for PHN?
Both help. Nortriptyline is usually preferred in older adults because it causes less drowsiness, dry mouth and dizziness on standing.
Does famciclovir treat postherpetic neuralgia?
No. Famciclovir treats the shingles attack and works best within 72 hours of the rash. Once PHN has developed, nerve pain medicines are needed instead.
Do lidocaine patches help shingles pain?
Yes, especially for pain from touch and clothing in a limited area. They are worn for up to 12 hours, then removed for 12 hours, on healed skin only.
Can gabapentin and nortriptyline be taken together?
Yes, under medical supervision. The combination can give better relief than either alone at lower doses, but drowsiness adds up, so the second drug starts low.
Why does my skin itch where I had shingles?
The itch comes from the damaged nerve, not the skin. Plasters, capsaicin and gabapentin or pregabalin help more than antihistamines.
Should I get the shingles vaccine if I already have PHN?
Usually yes, once the acute attack has settled. It lowers the chance of another shingles episode and more nerve damage. Ask your doctor about timing.
📑 Sources and editorial
- 📘 International guidelines on the drug treatment of neuropathic pain
- 🔬 Placebo-controlled trials of gabapentin, pregabalin and tricyclic antidepressants in postherpetic neuralgia
- 🩹 Studies of lidocaine 5% plasters and high-strength capsaicin patches in localised nerve pain
- 🔗 Randomised trial of gabapentin combined with nortriptyline in neuropathic pain
- 💊 Prescribing information for gabapentin, nortriptyline, amitriptyline, duloxetine and famciclovir
- 🛡️ Vaccine trials and public health guidance on the recombinant zoster vaccine
- 📖 Related reading: shingles and the 72-hour window, trigeminal neuralgia, diabetic neuropathy, treating herpes with valacyclovir, alcoholic neuropathy
- 🛒 Related products: Neurontin (Gabapentin), Gabatop (Gabapentin), Pamelor (Nortriptyline), Elavil (Amitriptyline), Cymbalta (Duloxetine), Famvir (Famciclovir)
- 🩺 RXshop Editorial Team — reviewed by James Carter, MD — Neurologist
Medical Disclaimer: The information in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek guidance from a qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition, and before starting, stopping or changing any medication.