Pain in Dementia: How to Spot It When a Person Cannot Say It Hurts, the PAINAD Scale and the Safest Painkillers
👵 A woman with moderate dementia starts shouting at the carer every morning. She pushes the hand away during washing, refuses to stand, and stops eating breakfast. The care plan says “agitation”. The real cause turns out to be an arthritic knee and a hip that hurts every time she is moved. Pain in dementia is common, often missed, and frequently mistaken for a behaviour problem. 🔍 People with dementia feel pain just as much as anyone else, but as memory and language fade they lose the words to say where it hurts, how much, and since when. This guide explains how families and carers can recognise pain without words, how the PAINAD scale works, which hidden causes to check first, and which painkillers are the safest choices in older age, from scheduled paracetamol and gels to nerve pain medicines and the drugs that are better avoided.
🧩 Why pain hides in dementia
🧠 Dementia damages the parts of the brain that turn a body signal into a clear message. The pain signal still arrives, but the person may not be able to name it, locate it or remember it long enough to report it. Asking “Are you in pain?” often gets a “no” from someone who is clearly uncomfortable, simply because the question is too abstract or the moment has passed. Some people use the wrong words, saying they are cold or tired when they hurt. Others stop talking about their body at all.
📉 The result is a well documented gap: people with dementia receive fewer painkillers than people of the same age without dementia, even after a hip fracture or with the same arthritis seen on X-ray. They are not in less pain. They are simply less able to ask for help. 📖 For an overview of the condition itself, see dementia and Alzheimer disease.
👥 Who is most at risk of untreated pain
🏥 Older age brings many painful conditions at once: worn joints, old fractures, a stiff spine, diabetic nerve damage, shingles scars, leg ulcers and constipation. The risk of pain going untreated rises as the dementia moves from mild to moderate and severe, because self report becomes less reliable with each stage.
🎭 When pain looks like a behaviour problem
⚡ In someone who cannot explain, pain comes out through actions. Agitation, shouting, hitting out during personal care, wandering, refusing food and sudden withdrawal can all be pain. These are often labelled as “behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia” and treated with sedatives, when the first question should be: could this person be hurting?
📖 A large care home trial in Norway tested a simple idea: give residents with dementia and agitation a stepwise pain treatment, starting with regular paracetamol, and see what happens to behaviour. Agitation fell in the treated group compared with usual care. The lesson is not that every agitated person needs a painkiller, but that a pain trial should come before sedatives.
👀 Six groups of pain signs to watch for
📋 Geriatric guidelines describe six groups of behaviour that suggest pain in people who cannot report it. Most people show a few of them, and the pattern is individual: a quiet person may become loud, a loud person may go silent.
📋 The PAINAD scale step by step
📏 PAINAD stands for Pain Assessment in Advanced Dementia. It takes about five minutes, needs no training beyond a short read, and can be used by nurses, carers and family members. The person is watched for a few minutes, ideally during movement such as turning in bed or standing up, because pain at rest is easy to miss. Each of five items is scored 0, 1 or 2.
| 🔎 Item | 0 points | 1 point | 2 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Breathing | Normal | Occasional laboured breathing, short period of fast breathing | Noisy laboured breathing, long period of fast breathing, pauses |
| Negative sounds | None | Occasional moan or groan, low speech with a negative tone | Repeated calling out, loud moaning, crying |
| Facial expression | Smiling or blank | Sad, frightened, frowning | Grimacing |
| Body language | Relaxed | Tense, distressed pacing, fidgeting | Rigid, fists clenched, knees pulled up, pulling away, striking out |
| Consolability | No need to console | Distracted or reassured by voice or touch | Cannot be consoled, distracted or reassured |
🔢 What the PAINAD score means
⚠️ PAINAD is not perfect. Fear, hunger, a full bladder or boredom can also raise the score, and some people in severe pain lie still and silent. The scale works best when combined with what family members know about the usual face and habits of the person.
📝 Other scales used in care homes
🔍 Hidden causes of pain to check first
🩺 Before reaching for a painkiller, it is worth doing a careful “head to toe” check. Many pains in older people with dementia have a simple, fixable cause that a tablet would only cover up.
🚽 Constipation and urinary retention
💩 Constipation is one of the most common and most overlooked sources of distress in dementia. Low fluid intake, little movement, iron tablets and many painkillers all slow the bowel, and the person may not remember the last time they opened their bowels. A blocked bowel can cause cramps, agitation, poor appetite and even overflow diarrhoea that looks like a stomach bug.
💧 Urinary retention, where the bladder cannot empty, is painful and can be triggered by medicines with anticholinergic effects, an enlarged prostate in men, or constipation pressing on the bladder. 📋 Carers can keep a simple bowel chart and a note of how often the person passes urine; three days without a bowel motion or very small, infrequent urine output deserves a call to the nurse or doctor.
🦷 Mouth and teeth: the forgotten pain
🪥 Dental pain is easy to miss because the mouth is rarely examined in routine care. Refusing food, chewing on one side, drooling, pulling at the cheek or taking the denture out repeatedly can all point to a painful tooth or a sore gum. Brushing becomes harder as dementia progresses, so decay and gum disease are common. A dental check at least once a year, and sooner when eating changes, is a simple step with a big payoff.
🌀 Is it pain or delirium?
⏱️ Delirium is a sudden change in attention and thinking, often over hours or days, and it is a medical emergency in older adults. Pain can trigger delirium, and so can the painkillers used to treat it, especially opioids, strong anticholinergic medicines and sedatives. Infection, dehydration, low sodium and a new medicine are other common causes.
📖 Gradual memory change is a different picture from delirium; see lowered cognitive functions in elderly patients for the reversible causes doctors check.
🪜 The stepped approach to treatment
📐 The guiding rule for painkillers in older people is “start low, go slow, but do go”. Under-treatment is as harmful as over-treatment: untreated pain worsens sleep, mood, appetite, walking and falls. Each step is reviewed with a pain score before moving on.
💊 A scheduled paracetamol trial
⏰ “As needed” painkillers work poorly in dementia, because they depend on the person asking. Giving paracetamol at fixed times, for example morning, midday, late afternoon and bedtime, removes that barrier. Many clinicians suggest a trial of one to two weeks with a PAINAD score or behaviour diary before and during the trial. If agitation, sleep or eating improve, pain was likely part of the problem.
📋 How a trial is usually set up
💊 500 mg to 1 g at fixed times, 3 to 4 times a day
📏 Total kept within the daily ceiling the doctor sets
📝 Pain score or behaviour notes each day
📊 What to look for
✅ Calmer during washing and dressing
✅ Better sleep, fewer night calls
✅ Eating and walking more
➖ No change: look for another cause
❌ New confusion: check for delirium
💡 A useful trick is to give a dose about 30 to 60 minutes before the most painful part of the day, often the morning wash or a physiotherapy session, so the medicine is working when it is needed most.
📏 Paracetamol dose limits in older adults
🧪 Paracetamol is the first choice because it does not irritate the stomach, does not raise blood pressure and does not affect the kidneys at normal doses. The danger is the liver, and the risk rises when the daily total is too high or when several products containing paracetamol are taken at once. Cold remedies, combination painkillers and some sleep products may all contain it.
| 👤 Situation | 📏 Usual daily ceiling | 📝 Why |
|---|---|---|
| Healthy older adult, normal weight | Up to 4 g | Standard adult maximum |
| Frail, weight under 50 kg | Often 3 g or less | Less liver reserve, lower body mass |
| Poor appetite, recent weight loss | Often 3 g or less | Low glutathione stores in the liver |
| Regular alcohol or liver disease | Doctor decides, often 2 g | Higher risk of liver injury |
| On warfarin | Agree with doctor | Regular high doses can raise INR |
🧴 Gels for painful joints
🦵 For pain in one or two joints, especially knees and hands, a diclofenac gel rubbed in three to four times a day gives local relief with far less of the drug reaching the blood than a tablet. That makes stomach bleeding, kidney strain and blood pressure rises much less likely, which is why guidelines on older adults prefer topical NSAIDs over tablets for osteoarthritis.
🧤 Carers should wear gloves or wash hands after applying, avoid broken skin and keep the gel away from the eyes. Gels can be combined with regular paracetamol, which is often enough for arthritis pain in daily life. 📖 For people with high blood pressure, blood thinners or weak kidneys, see osteoarthritis pain relief after 65.
⚠️ Oral NSAIDs and celecoxib: when and when not
🚫 Ibuprofen, naproxen and diclofenac tablets are effective but riskier in older age. They can cause stomach bleeding, kidney injury, fluid retention, high blood pressure and heart failure flares, and the risk climbs with age, dose and length of use. Geriatric prescribing lists advise against long-term use unless other options have failed and the stomach is protected.
| 💊 Medicine | ✅ May fit | ⛔ Usually avoided |
|---|---|---|
| Motrin (Ibuprofen) | Short course for a flare, lowest dose, with food | Kidney disease, heart failure, past ulcer, on blood thinners |
| Celebrex (Celecoxib) | Higher stomach risk where an NSAID is still needed, often 100 mg once or twice daily | Heart disease, past stroke, severe kidney disease |
| Any oral NSAID | Days to a few weeks, reviewed | Combined with another NSAID or with diuretic plus ACE inhibitor |
🩸 When an oral NSAID is used, a doctor will often add a stomach protector and check kidney function and blood pressure within a few weeks. Indomethacin and piroxicam are generally avoided in older adults because of their higher rate of side effects, including confusion with indomethacin.
⚡ Nerve pain: gabapentin and duloxetine
🔥 Burning feet from diabetes, lasting pain after shingles and sciatica do not respond well to paracetamol. Nerve pain medicines can help, but in dementia they must start at very low doses, because dizziness, sleepiness and unsteady walking raise the risk of falls and can deepen confusion.
📋 Gabapentin combined with an opioid increases the risk of breathing problems and heavy sedation, so the pair is used only with close supervision. Duloxetine is avoided when kidney function is severely reduced and needs care with blood thinners and other serotonin medicines. 📖 Pain and low mood often feed each other; see depression in chronic pain syndrome.
🛑 Medicines that can worsen confusion
🧠 Some medicines used for pain or sleep block acetylcholine, the same brain chemical that dementia medicines try to protect. Their combined “anticholinergic load” can cause confusion, constipation, urinary retention, dry mouth and falls. Older adult prescribing guidance lists them as drugs to avoid or use with great care.
💊 Opioids: small doses and close watching
🔎 For severe pain, after a fracture, in advanced cancer or when other options have failed, opioids should not be withheld just because a person has dementia. A low dose of morphine, oxycodone or a buprenorphine skin patch can restore comfort and sleep. The skill lies in the dose and the follow-up.
🚫 Why sedatives and antipsychotics are not pain relief
💤 When a person with dementia is distressed, it can be tempting to calm them with a sedative or an antipsychotic. These medicines may quieten the behaviour while the pain carries on underneath. Antipsychotics in older people with dementia are linked to a higher risk of stroke, falls, pneumonia and death, and regulators carry warnings about this. They have a narrow place for severe distress or psychosis, for the shortest time, after pain and other physical causes have been looked for and treated.
Pain check and a paracetamol trial
Change routine, environment and care approach
Antipsychotic for severe risk, short term, reviewed
🔗 Dementia medicines and painkillers together
🧪 Many people with Alzheimer disease take donepezil, rivastigmine or memantine. These are not painkillers, but they matter when pain treatment is planned. Donepezil and rivastigmine can increase stomach acid and slow the heart, so combining them with oral NSAIDs calls for extra care about stomach protection. Memantine can cause dizziness, which adds to the effect of gabapentin or opioids.
| 🧠 Dementia medicine | 💊 Point to watch with pain treatment |
|---|---|
| Aricept (Donepezil) | Stomach upset and bleeding risk with oral NSAIDs; slow pulse, fainting |
| Namenda (Memantine) | Dizziness adds to sedating painkillers; dose lowered in kidney disease |
| Any of them | Strong anticholinergic drugs work against their effect |
🌙 When pain disturbs sleep and appetite together with low mood, a doctor may consider Remeron (Mirtazapine) at night. It is not a painkiller and can cause daytime drowsiness and weight gain, so it is used for the mood and sleep problem, while pain is treated in its own right.
🤲 Comfort without tablets
💛 Non-drug measures are not a second-best option. For many people with dementia, how care is given changes pain as much as what medicine is given. Slow, explained movements, warmth and familiar faces reduce the fear that makes pain worse.
📓 A daily pain diary for families
✍️ Family members see patterns that a doctor in a ten-minute visit cannot. A simple diary kept for one or two weeks often settles the question of whether pain is driving the behaviour.
📅 Once pain is recognised, improvement often comes quickly. Many families notice calmer mornings within the first week, although the full picture needs a planned review.
Cause checked, regular paracetamol started
Calmer care, better nights in many people
Review: keep, adjust or add the next step
Medicine review, stop what is no longer needed
🗣️ Questions to ask the doctor or care home
💬 Families are often the only voice a person with advanced dementia has. It is reasonable to ask how pain is being assessed and treated, and to request a pain trial before any sedative.
- 📌 Which pain scale do you use, and how often is it scored?
- 📌 Is paracetamol given at fixed times or only when asked for?
- 📌 Has constipation, a urine infection or a dental problem been ruled out?
- 📌 Which of the current medicines could be adding to the confusion?
- 📌 Could a painkiller be tried before a sedative or antipsychotic?
- 📌 When will the pain plan be reviewed?
🗿 Myths about pain in dementia
🚨 When to see a doctor urgently
⛔ Get medical help the same day, or call emergency services, if:
🔹 The person cannot stand or bear weight after a fall, or one leg looks shorter or turned out.
🔹 Confusion has suddenly worsened over hours or days, or they are unusually drowsy.
🔹 There is fever, a hard swollen belly, vomiting, or no urine for many hours.
🔹 Breathing is slow, noisy or irregular after a new painkiller.
🔹 Black stools or vomiting blood while taking an NSAID.
🔹 The PAINAD score is 7 or more and does not settle.
❓ Frequently asked questions
How can I tell if someone with dementia is in pain?
Watch the face, sounds, body posture and reactions to touch, especially during movement. Grimacing, moaning, guarding a body part, resisting care and changes in eating or sleep are common signs.
What is the PAINAD scale?
It is a five-item observation tool for people with advanced dementia. Breathing, sounds, face, body language and consolability are each scored 0 to 2, giving a total from 0 to 10.
Can pain cause aggression in dementia?
Yes. Pain is one of the most common treatable causes of agitation, shouting and hitting out, especially during washing, dressing and transfers.
What is the safest painkiller for elderly people with dementia?
Paracetamol given at regular times is usually the first choice, often combined with a diclofenac gel for painful joints. Stronger medicines are added carefully if needed.
How much paracetamol can an older person take?
The standard adult maximum is 4 g a day, but for frail people, those under 50 kg, or with poor appetite or liver problems, doctors often set 3 g or less.
Is ibuprofen safe in older adults?
Only for short courses in carefully chosen people. It can cause stomach bleeding, kidney injury and fluid retention, so gels are preferred for joint pain.
Can gabapentin be used for nerve pain in dementia?
Yes, at a low starting dose adjusted to kidney function. Drowsiness, dizziness and falls are the main risks, so the dose is raised slowly.
Why is amitriptyline avoided in dementia?
It has strong anticholinergic effects that can worsen memory and confusion and cause constipation, urinary retention and falls.
Should antipsychotics be used for agitation caused by pain?
No. They hide the behaviour without treating the pain and raise the risk of stroke, falls and death in dementia. Pain should be checked and treated first.
How long should a paracetamol trial last?
Usually one to two weeks of regular doses, with a pain score or behaviour diary before and during the trial to see whether things improve.
📑 Sources and editorial
- 📘 Geriatric society guidance on persistent pain management in older persons
- 📋 Validation studies of the PAINAD, Abbey, PACSLAC and Doloplus-2 observational pain scales
- 🏥 Cluster randomised care home trials of stepwise pain treatment for agitation in dementia
- 💊 Criteria for potentially inappropriate medication use in older adults
- 🧪 Product labelling for paracetamol, diclofenac gel, celecoxib, ibuprofen, gabapentin, duloxetine and dementia medicines
- ⚠️ Regulatory safety warnings on antipsychotic use in older people with dementia
- 📖 Related reading: dementia and Alzheimer disease, lowered cognitive functions in elderly patients, osteoarthritis pain relief after 65, depression in chronic pain
- 🛒 Related products: Paracetamol 500mg (Acetaminophen), Emulgel (Diclofenac Gel), Jonac (Diclofenac Gel), Celebrex (Celecoxib), Neurontin (Gabapentin), Cymbalta (Duloxetine), Aricept (Donepezil)
- 🩺 RXshop Editorial Team — reviewed by Emily Chen, MD — Internal medicine
Medical Disclaimer: The information in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek guidance from a qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition, and before starting, stopping or changing any medication.